Abstracts Category : Other

Add abstract

Want to add your dissertation abstract to this database? It only takes a minute!

Search abstract

Search for abstracts by subject, author or institution

Share this abstract

The Fundamentality of Fit

by Christopher Howard

Institution: University of Arizona
Year: 2017
Posted: 02/01/2018
Record ID: 2171422
Full text PDF: http://hdl.handle.net/10150/625608


Abstract

Normative reasons for attitudes are facts that count in favor of those attitudes, but a fact can favor an attitude in two very different ways. One way in which a fact can favor an attitude is by making the attitude fitting (apt, merited, correct). For example, the fact that Sharon spends much of her time doing charity work is a fact that favors admiring Sharon, since its a fact that makes her admirable, and so fit to admire. Call any fact that favors an attitude by making it fitting a "fit-related reason."A second way in which a fact can favor an attitude is by making the attitude somehow valuable, or good to have. For example, the fact that an evil dictator will order my execution unless I admire him is a fact that favors my admiring the dictator, since it's a fact that makes my admiring him good. Call any fact that favors an attitude by making it somehow good to have a "value-related reason."This dissertation has two main goals. The first is to develop an ontology of normativity that can accommodate a view on which both fit- and value-related reasons are genuine reasons. Many authors, including Derek Parfit, T.M. Scanlon, and Mark Schroeder, favor a "reasons-first" ontology of normativity: they take reasons to be normatively basic, and claim that all other normative facts, properties, and relations can be analyzed or accounted for in terms of the reason relation. A central alternative, famously defended by G.E. Moore in Principia Ethica, is the "value-first" ontologyan ontology that takes value or goodness to be normatively basic and claims that the rest of the normative can be accounted for in terms of the property of being good. In the opening chapter of my dissertation, "The Fundamentality of Fit," I advance an ontology of normativity, originally suggested by Franz Brentano and A.C. Ewing, according to which fittingness is the basic normative relation, in terms of which the rest of the normative can be explained. I argue that neither the reasons- nor the value-first ontology can accommodate a view on which both fit- and value-related reasons are genuine reasons. Then I explain how my "fittingness-first" ontology can.Of course, any threat to the plausibility of the view that both fit- and value-related reasons are genuine reasons would undermine the case for my ontology of normativity. And so a full defense of my fittingness-first ontology will require a systematic defense of the substantive normative view it's designed to accommodate. The second goal of my dissertation is to provide this defense.A normative view that says that both fit- and value-related reasons are genuine reasons consists in three component claims: (1) that fit-related reasons are genuine reasons; (2) that value-related reasons are genuine reasons; and (3) that fit- and value-related reasons can be compared against one another to yield univocal verdicts concerning what attitudes one ought, all-things-considered, to have. The first of these claimsthat fit-related reasons are genuine reasonsis among the most widely shared inAdvisors/Committee Members: Timmons, Mark (advisor), Timmons, Mark (committeemember).

Add abstract

Want to add your dissertation abstract to this database? It only takes a minute!

Search abstract

Search for abstracts by subject, author or institution

Share this abstract

Featured Books

Book cover thumbnail image
Electric Cooperative Managers' Strategies to Enhan...
by White, Michael Edward
   
Book cover thumbnail image
Bullied! Coping with Workplace Bullying
by Gattis, Vanessa M.
   
Book cover thumbnail image
The Filipina-South Floridian International Interne... Agency, Culture, and Paradox
by Haley, Pamela S.
   
Book cover thumbnail image
Solution or Stalemate? Peace Process in Turkey, 2009-2013
by Yurtbay, Baturay
   
Book cover thumbnail image
Performance, Managerial Skill, and Factor Exposure...
by Avci, S. Burcu
   
Book cover thumbnail image
The Deritualization of Death Toward a Practical Theology of Caregiving for the ...
by Gibson, Charles Lynn
   
Book cover thumbnail image
Emotional Intelligence and Leadership Styles Exploring the Relationship between Emotional Intel...
by Olagundoye, Eniola O.
   
Book cover thumbnail image
Commodification of Sexual Labor Contribution of Internet Communities to Prostituti...
by Young, Jeffrey R.
   
Book cover thumbnail image
The Census of Warm Debris Disks in the Solar Neigh...
by Patel, Rahul I.
   
Book cover thumbnail image
Risk Factors and Business Models Understanding the Five Forces of Entrepreneurial R...
by Miles, D. Anthony